#archeology / a cautionary tale about biblical fundamentalism and ultranationalism
What was hailed as proof of biblical text now appears to be just an ancient fishing weight with natural corrosion, not writing. This serves as a cautionary tale about claims of proving/disproving aspects of the #Bible.
Nir Hasson discusses a controversial archaeological find - a small lead tablet supposedly containing ancient #Hebrew writing - that was heralded last year as proving the Bible's historical veracity. But mounting evidence suggests it is a hoax or mistake.
The lead tablet was unearthed illegally in 2021 at a West Bank site by Israeli settlers, not through proper archaeological excavation. Researchers claim it dates to the 13th century BCE and contains a curse with the Hebrew letters of God's name.
The artifact was proclaimed a monumental discovery by the researchers and Israeli politicians. But many experts now say there's no evidence of real writing, just scratches, pits and corrosion.
Three peer-reviewed articles were recently published, strongly doubting the claims about the tablet. Even one of the original researchers admits the tablet likely does not have complete words or letters.
The tablet resembles common fishing weights from the region. Given it was essentially dug up from back dirt, doubts were raised about it even originating from the time period claimed.
Many epigraphers and archaeologists now believe there is little basis for the sensational claims made about the tablet last year. The saga shows how the nexus of archeology and biblical fundamentalism can produce biased and questionable research.
Hebrew https://www.haaretz.co.il/science/archeology/2023-12-20/ty-article-magazine/.premium/0000018c-81b2-db89-ad8f-f3baa89f0000
@israel
@archeology
#ultranationalism