One of the big things I'm taking-away so far reading the platform -op book is that we really need a standards-based reputation/identity system.

I remember reading some protocol-level work on this a few years back when I was getting into architectures.

Clearly something that demands a decentralized approach.

@jjg as far as i can tell decentralized identity is really difficult. I think a big reason for the success of things like slack or facebook is that centralization helps control spam

@alienghic I thought facebook and slack were the *definition* of spam... ;)

Seriously though the approaches I remember revolved around hosting your identity on your own webserver under the same domain as your own email server and email was used as the identity "handle" (assuming I remember it correctly).

I've run my own email for years and see far less spam than I did when I used gmail/google apps, surprisingly.

@jjg cost of domain and difficulty running servers puts identity solutions based on that out of the reach of most people. I regularly see anonymous spammers on irc, something i don't on slack. Part of your less spam on your home domain may be due to others not finding it. I was getting away with pretty simple antispam techniques until i started contributing to Debian.

@alienghic Obscurity is certainly a factor, but I disagree that cost/difficulty are limiting factors.

I think a lot of effort has gone into convincing people that they are incapable of owning & operating these services but it's nothing compared to some of the other systems people consider essential (automobiles, for example).

@mayel @jjg That was a pretty neat collection of essays.

I think there's an advantage to some social network fragmentation. As there are many human cultures, and I worry that forcing everyone together really quickly is a recipe for anger and resentment.

@alienghic @mayel funny I was just talking about something along these lines at the coffee shop.

There’s some evidence that primates are not well-suited to live in large groups and systems which constrain their ability to split-up and move-around may be at the root of a number of perennial problems we experience.

@jjg @mayel I have this hunch that the modern Internet & globalization is to societies like having two continents merge is to species extinction events.


@alienghic @mayel I think that may be true, although I think the process pre-dates the Internet considerably (although the Internet certainly accelerates the process).

I believe it’s avoidable (at least theoretically ), but based on this mornings conversation the solutions may be counter-intuitive.

Need to do a substantial amount of research before I have more confidence.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!