Sorry for any misunderstanding -- I'm familiar with RMS, GNU, and the FSF, I'm mostly just having difficulty reconciling the benefits of FOSS with the detrimental effects of associating with RMS.
It seems like GNU is controlled by the FSF, which is controlled by RMS. I'd love to be corrected, but both the FSF and GNU seem to inherit all of the problems RMS brings to the table, which is a shame.
I'm sure better-qualified folks have talked more about this, but:
- inaccessibe to non-techy users
- authoritarian tendencies
- bad public relations
- really awful logos
Most people seem to be very put off by how RMS communicates his ideas to the world, and while I agree with free software I'm not sure that marketing from RMS, GNU, or the FSF is very effective.
@petit @mangeurdenuage I think that's a good attitude to have. I don't want him kicked out of any organizations, my only point is that it seems like he holds a majority of the power over organizations with thousands of members.
I support the goals of the FSF and GNU, but I'm not very interested in heavy-handed authorities -- especially when that means yielding to someone who many have problems with.
I wasn't saying that *I* would make a change, I asked whether GNU and the FSF are reasonable and worth paying attention to, or whether they're just extensions of RMS.
Ideally I'd like for the FSF and GNU to be democratic projects who can reach consensus on what to do and say rather than just act as mouthpieces for RMS.
From the outside, that doesn't seem to be the case, and that seems like a missed opportunity for free software as a whole.
I assure you the problem isn't a lack of familiarity. I've been using GNU software for over a decade and have nothing but respect for the maintainers, and I take no issues with fighting propriety and copyright.
Many people have concerns with how RMS behaves and represents the free software community, and it's frustrating to have these concerns waved away as "fashionable" rather than anyone taking responsibility or accounting for the concerns of the community.
The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!