Coops should scrap charitable donations and instead invest the money into new coops. Charity tackles symptoms, coops change structural root causes.

It would have a deeper, more sustainable social impact, improve the bottom line and distinguish coops more from capitalist firms.

Right now the charitable work coops do is indistinguishable from that of their capitalist competitors, at least to the ordinary member.

@LeoSammallahti totally an ignorant "outsider" view ... but aren't co-ops likely always grassroots organizations? It seems more feasible that multiple co-ops could pool money and form a bigger co-op to pursue larger goals.


Would put it this way - most co-ops are grassroots organisations, but the co-op sector as a whole is dominated by big giants, in the US entities like the Dairy Farmers Of America, ACE Hardware, credit unions, etc.

The SME co-op sector generally does a great job in supporting the movement, the big ones do a bad job.

Often co-ops do come together and merge into bigger co-ops, iirc Dairy Farmers Of America for example was a result of merging three dairy co-ops.

@LeoSammallahti informative, thanks. Would a separate high-level co-op funded by the 3 co-ops have done better than the 3 merging into a Dairy Farmers of America? If not, the bottom-up-but-devolved thought wouldn't be materially different from the top-down-but-assimilative one.

Intuitively, bottom-up-but-devolved atleast seems to have communication advantages; the grassroots co-ops' messaging would address the ground situation while their umbrella org's messaging'd be big-picture?


In terms of communication and public image there probably would have been some advantages as you point out - although there might also be some advantages in having a unified brand.

Would guess that the merger probably reduced costs - instead of having three boards of directors, you only need one, instead of each of them doing the bureaucratic work to abide by regulations separately, they only need to do it for the one entity, etc.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

A Fediverse instance for people interested in cooperative and collective projects.